Composition, Story, Characters, Ideas
1. What is the film (really) about (Idea, Message, Thought)?
2. What are the major (social) issues in the film (Themes)?
3. Did the film feel the right length or was it too long (Form and Meaning)? (Storytelling has problems?)
4. Were there any parts that were unclear or puzzling? (Itemize those you suspect. Dramatic analysis of composition in details).
5. Which parts felt slow (Composition: begining, middle, end — compare plot and story)?
6. Which parts were moving or otherwise successful and why?
7. What did you feel about _______________ (name of character)?
Conflict, inner conflict, moral choices, etc.
8. What did you end up knowing about ________ (situation or issue)?
CINEMATOGRAPHY (CAMERA WORK)
1. Do action match cuts flow smoothly?
2. Is screen direction maintained?
3. Have the locale is revealed to a first-time viewer?
4. Is the environment fully utilized by the characters and thus made active in the drama?
5. Is it apparent on-screen when a character changes body position?
6. Are convincing dialogue rhythms maintained, even when a cut takes place in the middle of a sentence?
7. Have you full exploited eye-line shifts?
8. Have you fully expanded moments of significant action and charged silences?
9. Do changes of scene rhythm occur convincingly with changes in characters’ perceptions, thought patterns, and actions?
10. Does the scene breathe (either moving us close or distancing us where psychologically necessary, switching us between subjective and objective camera positions for variety?)
11. Does the way you have shot and cut the material convey a point of view (that is, effectively reveal the state of mind of the main character)?
12. Are there any redundancies (of dialogue, action, angle, etc.)?
13. What does the scene imply about back-story and what might come after?
1. USE OF CAMERA1. Does the camera follow the movement of a character?
2. Does it lay out a landscape or a scene geography for the audience?
3. Does the camera move away from someone or something so we see more objectively?
4. Does the camera reveal significant information by moving?
5. Is the move really a reframing to accommodate a rearrangement of characters?
6. Is the move a reaction (panning to a new speaker, for instance)?
7. When do we directly experience a character’s POV?
8. What is the dramatic justification? To accommodate subject matter? To make you see a certain way?
2. USE OF SOUND1. Complimenting camera position?
2. Counterpointing camera perspective?
3. Uniformly intimate (voice-over, for instance)?
4. To build atmosphere and mood?
5. As punctuation?
6. To motivate a cut? (next sequence’s sound rises until we cut to it)
7. As a narrative devise? (dramatic sound)
8. To build, sustain, or defuse tension?
9. To provide rhythm?
10. To create uncertainty?
3. CUTS (What motivates each cut?)
1. Is there an action match to carry the cut?
2. Is there a compositional relationship between the two shots that makes the cut interesting and worthwhile?
3. Is there a movement relationship that carries the cut?
4. Does someone leave the frame (making us want to see a new frame)?
5. Does someone/something fill the frame, blanking it out and permitting a cut to another frame that starts blanked and then clears?
6. Does someone or something enter the frame and demand closer attention?
7. Are we cutting to follow someone’s eye-line, to see what they see?
8. Is there a sound, or a line, that demands that we see the source?
9. Are we cutting to show the effect upon a listener and what defines the moment to cut?
10. Are we cutting to a speaker at a particular moment that is visually revealing? What defines that moment?
11. If the cut intensifies our attention, what justifies that?
12. If the cut relaxes and objectifies our attention, what justifies that?
13. Is the cut to a parallel activity (that is, something going on simultaneously)?
14. Is there some sort of comparison or irony being set up through juxtaposition?
15. Are we cutting to a rhythm?
What is the relation of sounds to images?
1. Does it help identify the new image?
2. Does it give it a particular emphasis or interpretation?
3. Is the effect expected or unexpected?
4. Is there a deliberate contradiction?
Where and how is music used?
1. How is it initiated? (characters or story begin some kind of motion, action, emotion).
2. What does the music suggest by its texture, instrumentation, etc.?
3. How is it finished? (characters/story arrive at new location, the change)
4. What comment is it making? (ironic, sympathetic, lyrical, POV)